EXPLAINED: Why isn’t Norway an EU member?
Despite being offered the chance to join, Norway isn’t an EU member, but why is this? The Local looks at Norway’s relationship with the European Union and examines why it has chosen not to join.
Norway and the European Economic Community
Several times over the past 60 plus years, Norway has flirted with the idea of being a member of either the European Economic Community (EEC) or the European Union (EU). However, on every occasion, this has been met with firm opposition.
The country’s relationship with Europe dates back to the 60s, where its applications to join the EEC were done so reluctantly, according to Lise Rye, Professor of Contemporary European History at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU).
“Norway started out as a reluctant European, in the sense that it only applied for membership of the EEC in the 1960s because Great Britain did. I have never seen any evidence that suggests that Norway would have approached the EEC on her own,” Professor Rye explained to The Local.
The Norwegian government applied for membership twice in the 60s. Both applications ultimately led to nowhere. The negotiations were suspended both times when French President Charles De Gaulle vetoed the UK’s membership application.
At the time, the main argument for joining was for Norway to secure access to the country’s most important markets.
In 1972 Norway would have another chance to join, although this time it would be subject to a referendum. A majority of 53.5 percent voted against membership. What makes this result significant, according to Rye, is that Norway had not yet discovered oil in the North Sea, making it more of a cultural or ideological rejection compared to the result of the second referendum two decades later.
As the years went on, the country would remain split, albeit with a narrow “no” majority, on whether it should join Europe. Rye noted, though, that in the early 2000s, there was a slim majority in favour of EU membership when interest rates in Norway were high.
“EU membership has always been contested in Norway and is a question that has divided the population in two, almost equal, parts,” Rye said about the public’s perception of the EU over the years.
Why hasn’t Norway joined the EU?
By 1992 Norway signed the European Economic Area Agreement, but two years later would opt against becoming a full EU member again following another referendum.
By the time the second referendum came about, Norway had discovered vast oil reserves in the North Sea, making it one of the wealthiest nations on earth, meaning it could afford to remain outside the EU.
READ ALSO: Why is Norway such a wealthy nation?
Another reason why the country opted for EEA membership but turned down the chance to join the EU was due to being able to access the EU internal market without sacrificing its sovereignty to the EU.
“The EEA Agreement appeared as an option that would enable Norway to benefit from free and equal access to the EU internal market, without having to surrender parts of its sovereignty to the EU,” Rye explained.
Rye added that the EEA had benefitted Norwegian businesses by offering them predictability. The agreement also gave Norwegian citizens free movement across the EEA. However, the main advantage of EEA membership might be that it is a compromise.
“Perhaps the main benefit is that the EEA Agreement, as a compromise solution, has kept both opponents and proponents of full membership relatively happy, or equally dissatisfied,” Rye said.
Although, the EEA Agreement has come with some drawbacks.
“The major drawback of the EEA Agreement is that while from a formal perspective, it keeps Norwegian sovereignty in regards to the EU intact, the reality is that it works in ways that are detrimental to Norwegian democracy. We do not have a seat at the table where EEA legislation is adopted. We do not have the same possibility to hold decision-makers accountable as citizens of EU member states do,” Rye explained.
Could Norway join the EU in the future?
Despite turning down the chance to join the EU twice, Norway and the EU have a reasonably close relationship.
The EU is one of Norway’s most important trading partners, and Norway is the EU’s eight-largest trading partner. Norway also participates in many of Europe’s programmes, such as Europol and the European Defence Agency.
This relationship could become even closer still, according to Rye.
“I believe the current situation, where countries are turning their back on international law, and where competition between major players is becoming more fierce, is likely to result in an even closer relationship between Norway and the EU,” she said.
The closeness of this relationship has come under scrutiny from some, though.
“Norway’s relationship with the EU has become much more comprehensive than anyone envisaged back in 1992. Today, many Norwegians hold, and with good reason, I believe, that Norway’s cooperation with the EU exceeds the mandate that Parliament gave in 1992,” the professor said.
Nevertheless, despite the likelihood of Norway’s relationship with the EU becoming closer, it still seems unlikely that Norway would become a fully-fledged member in the future.
“A crisis,” Rye said when asked what it would take for Norway to join the EU.
Comments
See Also
Norway and the European Economic Community
Several times over the past 60 plus years, Norway has flirted with the idea of being a member of either the European Economic Community (EEC) or the European Union (EU). However, on every occasion, this has been met with firm opposition.
The country’s relationship with Europe dates back to the 60s, where its applications to join the EEC were done so reluctantly, according to Lise Rye, Professor of Contemporary European History at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU).
“Norway started out as a reluctant European, in the sense that it only applied for membership of the EEC in the 1960s because Great Britain did. I have never seen any evidence that suggests that Norway would have approached the EEC on her own,” Professor Rye explained to The Local.
The Norwegian government applied for membership twice in the 60s. Both applications ultimately led to nowhere. The negotiations were suspended both times when French President Charles De Gaulle vetoed the UK’s membership application.
At the time, the main argument for joining was for Norway to secure access to the country’s most important markets.
In 1972 Norway would have another chance to join, although this time it would be subject to a referendum. A majority of 53.5 percent voted against membership. What makes this result significant, according to Rye, is that Norway had not yet discovered oil in the North Sea, making it more of a cultural or ideological rejection compared to the result of the second referendum two decades later.
As the years went on, the country would remain split, albeit with a narrow “no” majority, on whether it should join Europe. Rye noted, though, that in the early 2000s, there was a slim majority in favour of EU membership when interest rates in Norway were high.
“EU membership has always been contested in Norway and is a question that has divided the population in two, almost equal, parts,” Rye said about the public’s perception of the EU over the years.
Why hasn’t Norway joined the EU?
By 1992 Norway signed the European Economic Area Agreement, but two years later would opt against becoming a full EU member again following another referendum.
By the time the second referendum came about, Norway had discovered vast oil reserves in the North Sea, making it one of the wealthiest nations on earth, meaning it could afford to remain outside the EU.
READ ALSO: Why is Norway such a wealthy nation?
Another reason why the country opted for EEA membership but turned down the chance to join the EU was due to being able to access the EU internal market without sacrificing its sovereignty to the EU.
“The EEA Agreement appeared as an option that would enable Norway to benefit from free and equal access to the EU internal market, without having to surrender parts of its sovereignty to the EU,” Rye explained.
Rye added that the EEA had benefitted Norwegian businesses by offering them predictability. The agreement also gave Norwegian citizens free movement across the EEA. However, the main advantage of EEA membership might be that it is a compromise.
“Perhaps the main benefit is that the EEA Agreement, as a compromise solution, has kept both opponents and proponents of full membership relatively happy, or equally dissatisfied,” Rye said.
Although, the EEA Agreement has come with some drawbacks.
“The major drawback of the EEA Agreement is that while from a formal perspective, it keeps Norwegian sovereignty in regards to the EU intact, the reality is that it works in ways that are detrimental to Norwegian democracy. We do not have a seat at the table where EEA legislation is adopted. We do not have the same possibility to hold decision-makers accountable as citizens of EU member states do,” Rye explained.
Could Norway join the EU in the future?
Despite turning down the chance to join the EU twice, Norway and the EU have a reasonably close relationship.
The EU is one of Norway’s most important trading partners, and Norway is the EU’s eight-largest trading partner. Norway also participates in many of Europe’s programmes, such as Europol and the European Defence Agency.
This relationship could become even closer still, according to Rye.
“I believe the current situation, where countries are turning their back on international law, and where competition between major players is becoming more fierce, is likely to result in an even closer relationship between Norway and the EU,” she said.
The closeness of this relationship has come under scrutiny from some, though.
“Norway’s relationship with the EU has become much more comprehensive than anyone envisaged back in 1992. Today, many Norwegians hold, and with good reason, I believe, that Norway’s cooperation with the EU exceeds the mandate that Parliament gave in 1992,” the professor said.
Nevertheless, despite the likelihood of Norway’s relationship with the EU becoming closer, it still seems unlikely that Norway would become a fully-fledged member in the future.
“A crisis,” Rye said when asked what it would take for Norway to join the EU.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.