• Norway edition

Indian grandparents in 'Norway nightmare' demo

Published: 27 Feb 2012 10:37 GMT+01:00 | Print version
Updated: 27 Feb 2012 10:39 GMT+01:00

The grandparents of two Indian children taken into protective care by Norwegian social workers staged a protest in New Delhi on Monday to demand the children's immediate return to their parents.

"The children are Indian citizens. Norway has no right to keep the children in foster care," the toddlers' grandfather Monotosh Chakraborty told AFP outside the Norwegian embassy where he and other relatives began a four-day protest.

The case has stirred emotions in India and took on a diplomatic dimension last month when Indian Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna demanded that Norway "find an amicable and urgent solution."

India on Monday sent a special envoy to Oslo to meet the Norwegian foreign minister and other officials to discuss the case.

The two children, aged three and one, were removed from their parents in May last year by the Norway's Child Protection Services (CPS) which deemed they were not receiving proper care at home in the south-western town of Stavanger.

The parents, Norwegian residents Anurup and Sagarika Bhattacharya, have rejected the allegation and are fighting to return to India with their children.

The Indian government has told Norway that the children are being deprived of the benefits of being brought up in their own cultural and linguistic environment and should return to India as soon as possible

The grandparents said they were hoping for a final decision in early March.

"We want our children back and we need no lessons from Norway on how to raise children," Chakraborty said.

"We just have one plea: Norway send our children home," he added.

On February 17th, the Norwegian authorities allowed the parents to see their children for the first time in three months.

The welfare services have refused to detail why the children were removed, citing confidentiality, but have said such moves are made only in situations that endanger the child or where the child's needs are not sufficiently met.

AFP (news@thelocal.no)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

2012-02-27 14:59:55 by strixy
Aurora, if socials ervices had more common sense than to remove the kids from parents because they ate with their hands and slept in one bed, they would not be going back to India. I wholeheartedly support the Indian family in their struggle. Norwegian social services do not value the bond between children and biological parents and are notorious for removing children on petty grounds.
2012-02-27 20:56:07 by VicTaulic
If the grandparents are so concerned, let's send them all back there and they will be happy and warmer.
2012-02-27 21:31:01 by strixy
I have been following BV cases for a while and I am positive that in many cases children are removed from homes on petty grounds. Yes, sure, if you are not prepared to adapt to some harmless cultural differencies (eating with hands at home is not necessarily honour killing...) then do not invite those people to Norway. I really do not see any sense in producing various propaganda films that are then screened in countries like India and invite people to come over if you reject everything that is non-Norwegian. There is no harm in eating with hands as there is no harm in sleeping in bed with parents. If BV was concerned, they surely should have supported the family to adapt to the Norwegian society instead of removing the kids. The fact that the way BV behaved is also a violation of international treaties and regulations seems to be of little concern, so I hope the same attitude will be adapted if for example Norwegian kids get to Indian custody for eating with knife and fork :D
2012-02-28 05:18:07 by xbrain
No wonder norwegians are so narrow minded in their own backyard, you have imminent dangers of the religous kind!!! Look around you and i will not be surprised if yr country is soon overrun by religous middle eastern communities...so pls dont go around telling these poor parents they need to succumb to yr laws!! No wonder norway,s kids never respect their parents!!! we adore and love our parents and look after them and NEVER send them to an old folks home..unlike you people who pack yr parents off to homes to rot and die!!! Shame on all of you... 2 months you deprive parents of their kids,,,
2012-02-29 11:45:06 by Gerald
The CPS wouldn't dare take away the children of Muslim parents. I dare to make a wager that they wouldn't even enter Muslim majority areas in Oslo.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)

Jobs in Norway

Hundreds of great job opportunities for foreign professionals at Norway's top employers - in cooperation with Monster and Experteer.
Choose location
Choose category
247 Jobs available
1 2 3 4 5    »    »»
Account Manager
Location: Oslo
added on 18/05 by
QA Lead
Location: Oslo
added on 17/05 by
Communications Manager
Location: Sandvika
added on 17/05 by
Lead Technical Assurance Engineer
Location: Sandvika
added on 17/05 by
Operations Engineer - Offshore Operations
Location: Stavanger
added on 17/05 by
Senior Project Manager
Location: Sandvika
added on 17/05 by
Naxys Norway Sales Leader
Location: Bergen
added on 17/05 by
Lead Engineer/Technologist
Location: Oslo
added on 17/05 by
Account Manager
Location: Oslo
added on 17/05 by
Project Controller
Location: Tranby
added on 17/05 by
SharePoint Online Senior Architect
Location: Oslo
added on 17/05 by
Software Development Engineer
Location: Norge
added on 17/05 by
CCG Controller
Location: Oslo
added on 17/05 by
Principal Engineer ? Structural Design and Analysis
Location: Stavanger
added on 17/05 by
Strategic Sales Executive - Outsourcing-
Location: Norge
added on 17/05 by
Planner / Offshore project planner
Location: Bergen
added on 17/05 by
Project controller
Location: Stavanger
added on 17/05 by
Structural Engineers, Asset Integrity Management
Location: Bergen
added on 16/05 by
Riser engineers
Location: Trondheim
added on 16/05 by
System Test Manager
Location: Oslo
added on 16/05 by
1 2 3 4 5    »    »»
Highlights
Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

Latest news from The Local in Germany

More news from Germany at thelocal.de

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Democracy, Human Rights and the Rule of Law in Europe: Strengthening the Impact of the Council of Europe’s Activities (Thu, 16 May)
- We meet at a very important moment. As we here from the Secretary General the founding principles of this organisation, democracy, human rights and the rule of law are again under pressure in Europa. We have to take that very seriously, said Minister of Foreign Affairs, Espen Barth Eide, in his statement at the Council of Europe's meeting.

The Niwano Peace Prize to Gunnar Stålsett (Thu, 16 May)
Ambassador Arne Walther gave this message on behalf of Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mr. Espen Barth Eide, at the award ceremony.

National statement by Norway’s Minister of Foreign Affairs Espen Barth Eide (Wed, 15 May)
"The great interest that that non-Arctic states are taking in the coming observership is a tribute to the good work we have done together. I think it is very important to welcome the new observers and to appreciate their interest to working with us on the basis of the principles that we have agreed to”, Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide said at the Arctic Council Ministerial meeting in Kiruna, ...

Arctic Council welcomes new observers (Wed, 15 May)
“I am pleased that six new countries and the EU have been granted observer status in the Arctic Council. This confirms the Arctic Council’s key position as an international forum for discussing Arctic issues,” said Minister of Foreign Affairs Espen Barth Eide, who is taking part in the Kiruna Ministerial Meeting.